From Thomas Paine to Artificial Intelligence! An evolutionary critique of capitalism

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.68906/umsh.euro.23.415

Keywords:

Evolutionary Capitalism, Philosophy of Economics, Artificial Intelligence JEL Code: B40, O30, P14 1

Abstract

While the scholarly literature robustly documents Artificial Intelligence (AI) as the latest phase in capitalism's evolutionary trajectory of enclosure, extraction, and accumulation, the explicit theoretical lineage from Thomas Paine's critique remains largely unexplored, with Marx rather than Paine serving as the dominant historical reference point for contemporary critiques of AI capitalism. By examining the relationship between artificial intelligence and capitalism, the literature review used in this article reveals limited direct engagement with Thomas Paine's historical critique, with only few studies explicitly invoking Paine's analysis of land enclosures as analogous to contemporary AI firms' enclosure of "economically relevant intellectual capacity”. The majority of the literature review anchor their evolutionary analysis in Marxist frameworks, tracing capitalism's development through periodization’s including industrial, financial, and digital phases, or Fordist to post-Fordist transitions. Despite varied theoretical approaches—Marxist, critical theory, political economy, and post humanist —the sources converge on characterizing AI as captured by capitalist interests rather than autonomous from them. This capture operates through mechanisms including platform lock-in, data extraction, and corporate concentration, producing documented consequences of technological unemployment, intensified inequality, and erosion of democratic processes. In this article alternatives are proposed, ranging from Paine-inspired universal basic income funded by data 150 EUROMEDITERRANEAN 23 taxation to public AI under democratic control and regulatory reform. This article uses a Hermeneutic/Normative methodological approach. Hermeneutic by reading Thomas Paine’s writings not just historically, but as living texts whose meaning evolves when confronted with AI and digital capitalism. Normative by evaluating whether capitalism’s trajectory—from Paine’s Enlightenment ideals to algorithmic governance—upholds or betrays values like liberty, equality, and reason.

Downloads

Published

2026-05-28

Issue

Section

Articles